By need · Verified 2026-11-22

Gift cards and customer rewards for Canadian local shops

Gift cards bring cash into your till before December and introduce brand-new neighbours to your shop. Rewards programs only pay off when your checkout stays fast and customers actually remember they are enrolled.

What matters in Canada right now

  • In Ontario and most Canadian provinces, consumer protection laws prohibit expiry dates on standard paid gift cards — make sure your digital gift card tool never sets an automatic expiration date on purchased balances.
  • Do not buy a CA$100/month loyalty app before you have a clean e-mail list. A good monthly e-mail to 1,500 regulars often outperforms a complicated points app that slows down your counter line.
Honest product comparison

Real options, real prices, and who each tool is wrong for

All pricing and product notes checked on 2026-11-22. No paid placements or fake ratings.

Product Verified pricing
Checked 2026-11-22
Best fit Who it is wrong for
Square Gift CardsFree to set up digital eGift cards; 2.5% load fee + standard processing when loading; free to redeem; custom physical plastic cards start around CA$1.05 each (checked 2026-11-22).Cafés, restaurants, spas, salons, and shops using Square POS that want holiday eGift cards and counter plastic cards ready in an afternoon.Businesses that do not run Square POS and want gift cards tied to Shopify or Jane App instead.
Square LoyaltyTiered Canadian monthly plans (CA$60, CA$100, and CA$140/month by monthly loyalty visits; 30-day free trial, checked 2026-11-22).High-frequency counters (coffee shops, sandwich spots, quick-service lunch counters) where customers visit 3+ times a month and enter their phone number right on the Square screen.Low-frequency businesses (like a plumber or a bi-annual salon visit) where a CA$60+/month loyalty subscription costs more than the extra visits it generates.
Smile.io (Canadian — Kitchener-Waterloo)Free up to 200 monthly orders; Essential US$15/mo; Standard US$79/mo; Growth US$199/mo (adds VIP tiers and points expiry); Smile Plus US$999/mo (checked 2026-11-22).Shopify retail stores and local makers with steady online repeat orders (coffee beans, skincare, pet supplies) who want points and friend referrals.In-person-only counters that do not run Shopify.
With WorkLocal

What our set-up desk handles for you

  • We set up your digital gift card checkout page, test loading and redeeming a card on your counter terminal, and add a clear 'Gift Cards' link to your website header.
  • We keep reward math dead simple (for example, '10th coffee free' or '$10 off after $150 spent') so staff can explain it in five seconds.
  • We pair gift-card promos with two timely e-mails a year — Mother's Day/spring and late November/December.

Sources checked