Moving your customer list without losing people (or landing in spam)
A practical step-by-step checklist for moving contacts between Mailchimp, Brevo, MailerLite, or your POS without accidentally e-mailing unsubscribed customers.
Most small businesses stay stuck on an expensive or clunky e-mail tool for years out of one understandable fear: "If I move my list, I will lose my customers or accidentally spam people who already opted out."
That fear is completely reasonable — and completely avoidable if you follow a calm, five-step move instead of exporting one messy spreadsheet and hitting send on Friday afternoon.
Step 1: Export TWO separate files from your old tool
Never export just your active subscribers. Export two distinct CSV files and label them clearly with today's date:
- Subscribed / active contacts (including their original sign-up date, source, and last purchase or order date so your Canadian CASL consent record travels with them).
- Unsubscribed, bounced, and complained contacts (your suppression list).
Why does the second file matter so much? Because if you also pull customer e-mails out of Square, Shopify, or your online ordering database later, someone who unsubscribed two years ago might still sit in your POS file. Importing your old suppression list into your new e-mail tool first (marked strictly as unsubscribed / blocklisted) guarantees they can never be re-added by accident. Remember: under CASL, e-mailing people after they withdrew consent is one of the fastest ways to draw CRTC enforcement — Indeed Canada paid a CA$200,000 undertaking in August 2026 specifically over messages sent after opt-out.
Step 2: Clean out dead addresses before importing
Old lists accumulate typos (gnail.com, hotmial.com) and abandoned work addresses. Sending to a pile of dead inboxes on day one of a new tool signals spam behaviour to Gmail and Microsoft.
- Drop hard bounces immediately.
- Separate contacts who have neither bought from you nor opened an e-mail in more than two years. Under CASL, implied consent from a purchase expires after two years anyway — unless you hold clear proof of express opt-in, do not move stale two-year-old leads onto a promotional list.
Step 3: Wire DNS authentication before you upload a single contact
Before importing your list into Brevo, MailerLite, Kit, or Klaviyo, add your sending domain and configure three DNS records at your domain registrar or Cloudflare:
- SPF (says which mail servers are allowed to send on behalf of your domain),
- DKIM (adds a cryptographic signature proving the e-mail really came from you), and
- DMARC (tells Gmail and Yahoo how to handle mail that fails checks; Gmail's sender guidelines allow starting with
p=nonewhile monitoring).
Check Google's own sender rules (verified November 22, 2026): Gmail requires SPF or DKIM for all senders, SPF + DKIM + DMARC + one-click unsubscribe for bulk senders, and spam complaint rates kept below 0.30% in Postmaster Tools. Register your domain in free Google Postmaster Tools the same afternoon you set up DNS.
Step 4: Warm up with your best customers first
If your list has 1,500+ contacts, do not blast all 1,500 on the first afternoon from a brand-new provider. Send your first note to your 200 to 400 most recent customers or most engaged openers. Good opens and zero spam clicks tell Gmail and Outlook that your new setup is trustworthy. Send to the rest of your active, consented list a few days later.
Step 5: Swap every sign-up form and keep the old account quiet for 30 days
Before cancelling your old e-mail tool, check every place new e-mails enter your business: your website footer, your online ordering checkout, your counter QR card, and any booking or POS sync. Point each one to the new tool and run a test sign-up with your own personal e-mail address. Keep a local archive of your old CSV exports for at least three years as proof of consent, then cancel the old subscription once a full billing cycle runs cleanly.
Want a hand setting this up?
We pick the right software with you, do the wiring cleanly, and stay on to help after. You own every account and customer list.